Even flawlessly machined gears, composed of ideal materials and taken care of appropriately, can eventually fail after enough time. In this paper, the three major gear failure modes pitting, tooth root breakage and flank fracture will be discussed. In this paper the experimental results of a number of research projects with greases ranging from nlgi 00 to nlgi 1 using the fzg backtoback gear test rig are evaluated in context. Subcomponents failure modes main causes gears fretting corrosion vibration among gear tooth surfaces bending fatigue excessive stress on gear tooth bearings cracking inhomogenous cooling abrasion contamination of lubricant oil scuffing the texture of surface is rough lubricant oil.
Gear failure modesimportance of lubrication and mechanics. Summary this is a threepart article explaining the principles of gear lubrication. The second of a four part article contains an indepth discussion of the gear tooth failure modes that are influenced by lubrication. The different modes of gear failure are as shown in figure 1. In both cases, we are interested in the tooth load, which we got from the torque, t. When a failure arises from this cause there are often other adjacent teeth showing cracks at an earlier stage of development. Coupling credible failure modes and owner options to intervene. Tooth bending fatigue is one of the most common modes of fatigue failure in gears.
The nasa spiral bevel gear fatigue test rig was used to produce unneeded fault, natural failures of four face gear specimens. Failures are a result of excessive cyclic bending stresses applied to. Oil is picked up by each tooth and carried around the. The worm drive has been an active and challenging topic of. Gearbox typical failure modes, detection and mitigation methods.
Ansiagma 1010f14 appearance of gear teeth terminology. Adhesive and abrasive wear are important modes of wear. Categories technology engineering what is a gear tooth. Press releases american gear manufacturers association. The agma code defines a transmission accuracy level number, q, which reflects these latter high q implies low excitation, a low q refers to low accuracy and high vibration and suggests the k. Ratio on asymmetric spur gear tooth bending stress sharatchandrai r karagi1 and prashant s patil1 corresponding author.
Msi was contracted by the oem to perform testing and analysis to determine the root cause of gear tooth failures on an aeroderivative gas turbine power generation drivetrain. Department of energy, office of energy efficiency and renewable. This is a major cause of gear failure accounting for nearly 60% of the gear failures. Comparison of tooth interior fatigue fracture load. Detecting gear tooth fracture in a high contact ratio face. Gear dedendum wear on the dedendum of the driving tooth, as the driven tooth slides downward, the driving tooth surface is subjected to tension, surface fatigue results, and the tooth wears. Gear surface pitting failure and pitting life analysis. Bending stress leading to tooth breakage which is a maximum at the tooth root, and compressive stress leading to pitting, which reaches a maximum value at the tooth face.
These three modes will be investigated further, and the importance of using the right material to avoid these failures will be highlighted. As the gears counterrotate, the separating gear teeth create a vacuum, drawing oil into the inlet. A local geartooth defect such as a fatigue crack, pit, or chip weakens a tooth and causes transient. Gear failures can be traced to mechanical problems or lubricant failure. We have seen how to evaluate 15 the damaging fatigue load on a gear tooth, f, due to the torque transmitted combined with the quality of the gear s manufacture and its operating environment. Yet, to adequately manage the safety risks of a coupling failure, we must also entertain what failure modes are credible, the details of how each failure mode takes place and finally, what our options are to intervene in time. Gearbox reliability collaborative gearbox 1 failure.
High tooth asperities are polished off revealing contact surface area with the meshing gear. Mechanical testing of gears mechanical testing and. Principles of linear elastic fracture mechanics were used. Tooth bending and surface contact fatigue are two of the most common modes of fatigue failure found in gears. Under repeated loading due to fatigue gears can be damaged by two types. A new highspeed, highcycle, geartooth bending fatigue test capability nasatm2011217039 june 2011 david b.
Dec 18, 2017 gear tooth failure, prevention of tooth failure, definition of gear, types of failure, bending failure, wear failure, pitting, scoring, abrasive wear failure. Wear describes a loss or removal of material of gear flanks. Grindhonesuperfinish gear teeth coat gear teeth with phosphate, cu, ag use highviscosity antiscuff lubricant. The gears normally fail at two different regions of the gear tooth flank or tooth root. It should be used in conjunction with ansiagma 1010e95 in which the gear tooth failure modes are defined. Figure 1 expected crack propagation paths for tiff 1 left and tff 4 right. Introduction to gears nomenclature, speed and torque ratios of a pair of gears.
Pictures of gear tooth failure modes this document describes common types of gear tooth failure modes. At the same time, where the driven tooth addendum surface is in compression, fatigue can not occur. For example, if tooth contact patterns indicate misalignment or interference, inspect the gear for accuracy on gear inspection machines. Basically, the performance of a pair of gears can be assessed by the measure of success achieved in providing a positive drive, while operating at the requisite speeds, transmitting the maximum designated power. A necessity for correct meshing conjugate tooth action the involute what it is and why its a suitable shape for gear teeth. Pitting is a surface fatigue failure due to repetitions of high contact stresses. These craters are formed due to the high amount of compressive contact stresses in the gear surface occurring during transmission of the torque or in simple terms due to compressive fatigue on the gear tooth surface. Gear tooth failure problem resolution msi was contracted by the oem to perform testing and analysis to determine the root cause of gear tooth failures on an aeroderivative gas turbine power generation drivetrain. The new combined standard expands the nomenclature for general modes of gear tooth wear and failure. Find gear tooth failure related suppliers, manufacturers, products and specifications on globalspec a trusted source of gear tooth failure information. Stress analysis of helical gear by finite element method govind t sarkar1, yogesh l yenarkar 1 and dipak v bhope corresponding author. To design the gear closer to the power density limit, a high level of information concerning the load carrying capacity for the specific failure mode is necessary. The appearance of the various distress and failure modes can differ between gears that have through hardened teeth and.
The most critical function provided by lubricants is to minimize friction and wear to extend equipment service life. An improved fmeca method for wind turbines health management. The transition line between shiny, polished surface where the contact with the mating gear occurs and the rest of the tooth \ is smooth, no step is present indicating a minimal amount of wear. When a gear base pitch and a mating pinion base pitch is not equal to the operating base pitch of the. Research labora tory a new highspeed, highcycle, geartooth. This information sheet describes many of the ways in which gear teeth can fail and recommends methods for reducing gear failure. This standard provides nomenclature for general modes of gear tooth wear and failure. Pitting is the formation of craters on the gear tooth surface. Failures in root fillets are primarily due to bending fatigue but can be precipitated by sudden overloading impact. The analytical work consisted of investigating and applying several gear mesh failure predication techniques. Lubricantrelated failures are usually traced to contamination, oil film collapse, additive depletion, and use of improper lubricant for the application. Part 1 classifies gear tooth failures into five modes and explains the factors that a gear designer and operator must consider to avoid gear failures.
As before, analysing and diagnosing gear failures is all about recognising the visual signs associated with typical failure modes. Various defects in gear the general types of failure modes in decreasing order of frequency include fatigue failure, impact fracture, wear and stress rupture. Many modes of gear failure have been identified, for example fatigue, impact, wear or plastic deformation. The design of the asymmetric tooth shape reflects this functional difference. Tooth wear or surface deterioration a abrasion, b pitting, and c scoring or seizure 6. The four noteworthy failure modes in gears are contact fatigue, tooth bending fatigue, surface wear and scoring. During the fatigue tests, which were run to determine load capacity and primary failure mecha. The characteristics of this failure mode are discussed in detail and a number of actual case studies are presented which show the occurrence of this failure mode. Pdf the failure investigation of a gear should be planned carefully to preserve evidence. Gears are moving parts in complex systems, and as a result, they tend to deal with a lot of wear and tear over time. The workload on one profile is significantly higher and is applied for longer periods of time than for the opposite one. If the primary failure mode is likely to be influenced by gear geometry, check for any geometric or metallurgical defects that may have contributed to the failure. Gearbox reliability collaborative gearbox 1 failure analysis report. Tooth the two profiles sides of a gear tooth are functionally different for many gears.
For each of the factors, two levels, low and high, have been considered. Stresses on spur gear teeth the two primary failure modes for gears are. To estimate the tooth s life as a result of each failure mechanism, this load is applied to a geometrically simplified model of the tooth, viz. Tiff and tff failures can appear at loads below the allowable loading conditions for pitting and bending fatigue failure modes based on internationally. Tooth bending fatigue failures in gears sciencedirect. And the result of this study indicate that the teeth of helical gear failed by fatigue with a fatigue crack initiation from destructive pitting and spalling region at one end. In an analysis of more than 1,500 gear failure studies, the three most common failure modes were tooth bending fatigue, tooth bending impact, and abrasive tooth wear 4. It results in progressive damage to gear teeth and ultimately leads to complete failure of the gear. Zakrajsek purdue university, west lafayette, indiana robert f. It can be very easy for machinery specialists to overinvest. Pdf failure analysis of a helical gear researchgate. Gear tooth crack propagation was simulated using a finite element based computer program. Hydraulic gear pump and motor failure analysis and repair. The nonhunting gear ratio, with a common factor of three, caused the damage to imprint on every third tooth.
Liou and stefan rakuff introduction a worm drive is a geared power transmission device in which a worm meshes with a worm gear to transmit power between two nonintersecting shafts that are oriented at a right angle. Probabilistic simulation approach to evaluate the tooth. Gear tooth failures occur in two distinct regions, namely, the tooth flank and the root fillet. The article the lubrication of gears part 1 appeared in the marchapril 1991 issue of gear technology. Influences on failure modes and loadcarrying capacity of greaselubricated gears hansjorg schultheiss, johannpaul stemplinger, thomas tobie and karsten stahl in order to properly select a grease for a particular application, a sound knowledge of the influence of. The primary failure mode of the hs gearset was severe scuffing. October 6, 2009, revealed that the highspeed stage gear teeth showed signs of significant.
For each of the designs, the cirf throughout the tooth was calculated. The goal was to determine whether cracks grew through gear teeth benign failure mode or through gear rims catastrophic failure mode for various rim thicknesses. The 37 mw gearbox had broken pinion teeth after several thousand operating hours. Comparison of tooth interior fatigue fracture load capacity. Army research laboratory, glenn research center, cleveland, ohio andrew j. It also gives methods for preventing gear tooth failures. A long term failure mode, see step 10 on lubrication. Al and langlois 12 previously used this study to validate the proposed methodology.
Gearbox typical failure modes, detection, and mitigation. This is a threepart article explaining the principles of gear lubrication. Five common gearbox failures and how to identify them north. Five common gearbox failures and how to identify them. There are two failure modes that are important causes of gear tooth failures. Background gearbox typical failure modes bearings gears. Bending fatigue failures occur when the stress at the root of the gear tooth exceeds the capability of the gear material. Tooth breakage is unmistakably the most noticeably worst harmful. The location of the crack initiation distinguishes this failure mode from other fatigue failure modes. Learning gear essentials from dudleys handbook machine.
In terms of gear failure, it is more a deterioration of a gear profile, for instance, a damage of a tooth layer. The root cause of the scuffing was probably trapping of debris. Involute tooth form formula derivation involute tooth form formula derivation tooth wear nomenclature click on the link below. It provides guidance for those attempting to analyze gear failures. Gear tooth failure, prevention of tooth failure, definition of gear, types of failure, bending failure, wear failure, pitting, scoring, abrasive. Mechanical diagnosis and prognosis of military aircraft. The most common failure modes of printed gears are. Tooth breakage due to static and dynamic loads, and 2. This article describes the common failure modes such as scoring, wear, and pitting, on tooth flanks. Related searches for gear tooth failure modes related searches gear tooth failure.
Of these, one of the most common causes of gear failure is tooth bending fatigue. Probabilistic simulation approach to evaluate the toothroot. This type of pitting can be avoided by providing smooth geartooth surfaces and gear tooth contact patterns that distribute the load evenly across the. Mechanical tests are performed to evaluate the durability of gears under load. Profile modification is the term used to describe small changes in a gear tooth profile from the theoretical conjugate profile, to compensate for manufacturing errors and for changes in the tooth shape under load. Gearbox typical failure modes, detection and mitigation. Bending fatigue is a failure mode that affects gear teeth. Gears wear, failure and lubrication engineers edge. Learning gear essentials from dudleys handbook machine design. National renewable energy laboratory national wind technology center. Continuing our series on articles on how to diagnose different machinery failures, this page looks at the failure of gears.
How to diagnose gear failures neale consulting engineers. This crack ends up in failure of tooth giving a halt to the whole transmission system. Apr 01, 2014 five of the most common gear and bearing failure modes, along with tips on identification and potential means of prevention, are provided below. The transition line between shiny, polished surface where the contact with the mating gear occurs and the rest of the tooth\ is smooth, no step is present indicating a minimal amount of wear. Scuffing and other failure modes are not covered by isotr 14521. Tooth bending fatigue is one of the most common modes of fatigue. An introduction to spur gears meshing and reliability. If the application is critical or just cumbersome to replace a broken gear on then you may as well print the gear mostly solid to avoid the chance of any nonwear related failure. Optimization of power density by local gear failure modeling. Gearbox reliability collaborative gearbox 1 failure analysis. The annulus gear wear pattern indicated that the load distribution was heavier at the rotor end of the teeth.
1353 447 1366 861 1562 490 1350 1501 1500 1107 330 238 845 513 446 647 1160 535 834 1517 1261 1373 1082 1020 66 1154 765 1188 497 16 1445 1288 741 1473